Sharon Dolin

Quandary
July 26, 2025 Dolin Sharon

Quandary

 

Yamina arrived one morning to clean my rooms,
wearing black leggings, long-sleeved blouse,
her hair covered up by a headscarf, despite the
summer heat. I liked her instantly—could sense

 

her gentle spirit, she had entered timidly not
expecting me to be there. I greeted her, waved
her in. Returned to my desk, revising a poem
based on a psalm. She started in the living room

 

while I continued in the bedroom, listening
to women’s voices singing acapella
in Hebrew—which she could probably hear
and might find upsetting. Who knows what she

 

felt about Jews. I felt our disparity: she, sweeping
my floor while I led a poet’s life—having been
granted this seaside apartment for a month. I knew
she must be Muslim. I had seen several Muslim

 

women covered up at the beach, could detect
no trace of Jews. Perhaps they blended in
like me who always covers up my identity—
never wearing a Star of David in the open.

 

Should I switch off the music? I wondered,
wanting her to be comfortable. Yet she
had entered my space. Was it the same
as when I enter a taxi and Arabic music is

 

playing? Except I love its plaintive
songs. And she? What did she love
or hate? It must have been no more
than two minutes when I switched

 

to Chopin’s Études. Did I do the right thing?
Why do I always feel I have to cover up
who I am? Especially now when hatred
has sprung up again persistent as bamboo

 

whose rhizomes stretch far beneath the earth.

 

Sharon Dolin is the author of seven books of poetry, most recently Imperfect Present (University of Pittsburgh Press2022)a prose memoir Hitchcock Blonde (Terra Nova Press, 2020); and two books of translation from Catalan, most recently Late to the House of Words: Selected Poems by Gemma Gorga (Saturnalia Books, 2021), winner of Saturnalia Books Malinda A. Markham Translation Prize and a Finalist for the 2022 Griffin Poetry Prize. The recipient of an NEA Fellowship, Fulbright Scholarship, AWP Donald Hall Prize, Pushcart Prize, and Witter Bynner Fellowship, Dolin is Associate Editor of Barrow Street Press and teaches poetry workshops in New York City. https://sharondolin.com